How to combat the counter offer

If you are responsible for recruitment within your team or organisation you’ve no doubt experienced how competitive the current candidate market is. The number of vacancies listed in the healthcare sector is growing, yet with border restrictions and the fear of uncertainty, there are fewer candidates actively applying for roles.


Active job seekers hold the power with many being in situations where they have multiple offers on the table, from both other opportunities or their current employers in a bid to retain them. In order to ensure a successful recruitment outcome for your vacancy, you must anticipate that multiple and counteroffers are more prevalent than ever and could impact your recruitment process. 


At every touchpoint engage with your candidate, seek to understand what other roles they are considering or in the process for. This will help discover the appeal of other opportunities and understand how your offer is positioned against them. Benchmark your offer (remuneration and benefits) to ensure it meets what others in the market are offering. This doesn’t necessarily mean increasing the salary (although in some instances this will work) there are other factors equally important to job seekers in the current market. Work/life balance has fast become one of the biggest motivating factors for candidates to seek a new opportunity, evaluating your roster structure to accommodate this will help your opportunity stand out. The ability to be flexible with your offer demonstrates to a candidate that you invested in a long term partnership with them. 


In order to mitigate the risk of your preferred candidate accepting a counter offer there are steps you can take from the start to set yourself up for success. First and foremost, a clear timeline from the 1st interview through to the job offer will provide structure and keep the wheels moving.  Regularly check in with your applicants to keep them engaged - even letting them know there are no updates is an update to them. If there are multiple stakeholders involved that will be a part of your 2nd or 3rd interview book those interview times in their calendars from the outset - the scramble to align everyone’s schedules towards the end of the process adds pressure and stress that can easily be avoided by organising this in advance. Time is precious and waiting for calendars to align could mean the difference between a candidate accepting an offer that has already been presented to them instead of waiting for you. 


Ensure you and your team are ready to sell your brand and promote all the great things about working in your business. When engaging a potential new hire, share the importance of the role, the challenges they may face (for many candidates this is a positive opportunity for them to make a difference to your organisation and customers), outline the training that will be provided throughout onboarding and ongoing and lastly share examples of others in your business; when they started, how they progressed and the long-term progression pathways available within the company. Be honest and open, there should be no questions left unanswered - the more information a candidate has, the easier it is for them to make the decision to join your team. 


Checklist:

  • Your position description is up to date and ready to share
  • Process and timeline in place and all stakeholders engaged (ideally 5-10 days max)
  • Market checked your remuneration and benefits on offer
  • Does your job advertisement position the vacancy well to stand out in this market?
  • Candidate engagement plan - all aboard and ready to sell your organisation and job opportunity


Our team has experienced the surge in counteroffers firsthand, they’re more than happy to chat with you in more detail about how your business can overcome this and ensure you have a successful recruitment outcome.


By RWR Group Marketing • September 27, 2026
Shortage periods don't have to mean short-staffed. The venues that plan ahead hire well before the pressure hits. Why Shortage Periods Catch Venues Out Every hospitality operator knows the cycle. Peak season hits, experienced staff are in short supply, and venues scramble. But the venues that suffer most are the ones that started looking too late. Shortage periods aren't a reason to lower your standards. They're a reason to plan further ahead. Broaden Your Permanent Candidate Criteria If you're only hiring people with the exact venue type and years of experience you had in mind, you're shrinking your own pool during the tightest market. Look at transferable experience. A strong assistant manager from a different venue style can often step up faster than you'd expect, with the right onboarding. Build a Permanent Talent Pipeline Ahead of Time The smartest operators don't start recruiting when they're short. They keep a warm pipeline of experienced candidates who aren't actively job hunting but would move for the right permanent role. This means staying in touch with good people even when there's no vacancy today. Retention Beats Recruitment Every Time The cheapest way to survive a shortage period is not to lose people in the first place. Look at your busiest periods honestly. Are your permanent managers supported, or stretched thin and one bad week from leaving? Simple retention moves that matter: Clear rosters published early Real recognition, not just a pizza on a Friday A visible path to the next role, so people can see a future with you Creative Permanent Hiring Solutions That Work Cross-train existing permanent staff into stretch roles ahead of the crunch Fast-track your interview process specifically during known shortage windows Partner with a specialist recruiter who already has a warm bench of permanent hospitality candidates ready to go Revisit your salary benchmarking before the shortage hits, not during it None of this is about filling shifts with whoever's available. It's about building a permanent team strong enough to handle the pressure when it comes. KEY TAKEAWAYS Shortage periods are predictable. Plan your permanent hiring months ahead, not weeks. Broaden your criteria for transferable experience and potential. Retention is your cheapest recruitment strategy. A specialist partner keeps a warm pipeline ready before you need it. Hospoworld builds permanent hospitality teams that hold up under pressure, across New Zealand and Australia. Let's talk before your next shortage period hits: www.hospoworld.com/contact-us .
By RWR Group Marketing • September 23, 2026
Running one great venue is hard. Running five with the same standard? That's where most multi-site operators fall down. The Multi-Venue Challenge One strong GM can carry a single site. Across multiple venues, you need a system, not a hero. The moment you rely on one brilliant manager to hold everything together, you've got a single point of failure. Hire Leaders Who Can Replicate Your Standards Look for managers who've run tight, consistent operations before, not just charismatic operators. Ask candidates how they've trained others, not just how they've performed themselves. The best multi-venue hires are teachers as much as leaders. Build a Bench, Not Just a Roster High-performing multi-site teams have depth. When your head chef at venue two goes on leave, you need someone ready to step up, not a scramble. Invest in assistant managers and 2ICs as future venue leaders, not just support staff. Standardise What Matters, Localise What Doesn't Service standards, training, and reporting should look the same everywhere. Menu quirks, local partnerships, and team personality can flex. Confusing the two is where multi-venue consistency breaks down. Communication Across Sites Weekly cross-venue check-ins matter more than any piece of software. Give your venue managers a forum to compare notes, flag issues early, and learn from each other. Isolated venues become inconsistent venues. Recruit Ahead of Need The best multi-venue operators don't wait until a venue is short-staffed to start looking. They build relationships with strong candidates before a gap opens up. STAT SNAPSHOT Multi-site hospitality groups with structured leadership training report significantly lower manager turnover than those without one Venues with a documented 2IC succession plan fill leadership gaps faster when someone leaves. Teams with regular cross-venue manager meetings report stronger consistency in service standards. Building a team that performs the same way, at every venue, on every shift, doesn't happen by accident. It takes the right people in the right seats, and a plan for when they move on. Hospoworld specialises in permanent hospitality recruitment across NZ and Australia, at every management level. Let's help you build a bench that's ready for growth. Talk to us at www.hospoworld.com/contact-us . 
By RWR Group Marketing • September 20, 2026
Think recruitment agencies just take a cut and send your CV into a black hole? Used properly, they can get you hired faster, at a better rate, than applying solo ever will. Why Hospitality Candidates Hesitate Plenty of managers and chefs have been burned before. A recruiter who didn't listen. A role that didn't match the brief. It's put people off the whole idea. But a specialist agency, one that knows hospitality, works differently. What a Good Agency Does The right recruiter isn't just a middleman. They: Know roles before they're advertised publicly Understand the venue, the culture, and the GM you'd be working for Negotiate salary and package on your behalf Give you honest feedback, including when a role isn't right for you How to Get the Most Out of the Relationship Be upfront about what you want. Salary, location, venue type, career stage, all of it. The clearer you are, the better matches you'll get. Ask questions back. A good recruiter should be able to tell you about the team, the reporting line, and why the role is open. Stay in touch even when you're not actively looking. The best opportunities often come to people who aren't desperate for one. Red Flags to Watch For They can't tell you who the employer is before you apply They push you toward a role that doesn't match your brief They go quiet after your interview They know nothing about the hospitality sector specifically Why Specialist Beats Generalist A generalist recruiter juggles retail, admin, and hospitality roles all at once. A specialist like Hospoworld focuses only on permanent hospitality placements across NZ and Australia. That means we already know your world: service standards, venue politics, and what good looks like. QUIZ: Is Your Recruiter Working For You? 1. Have they told you the salary range upfront? 2. Do they know your industry, not just your CV? 3. Have they given you feedback, even on a knock-back? 4. Would you introduce them to a friend looking for work? Mostly yes? You've found a good one. Mostly no? It's time to talk to Hospoworld. Ready for a recruiter who gets hospitality? Visit www.hospoworld.com/contact-us and let's talk about what's next for your career.
By RWR Group Marketing • September 18, 2026
Good managers and chefs aren't sitting on job boards. They're already employed, already good at their jobs, and already getting calls from someone else. The Hospitality Hiring Market Has Flipped For years, employers held the cards. Now experienced hospitality Candidates do. Skilled GMs, head chefs, and venue managers across NZ and Australia know their worth, and they have options. If your venue is still recruiting like it's 2015, you're losing good people before you even meet them. What Experienced Candidates Want Money matters, but it's rarely the whole story. The Candidates you want are looking for: A clear career path, not just a job description Real information about culture and team, not corporate spin Respect for their time throughout the process - Leadership that backs them, not micromanages them Speed Wins Roles Hospitality talent has multiple conversations happening at once. If your process takes three weeks and five interview rounds, you'll lose them to the employer that moves in five days. Tighten your process: One clear decision-maker Interviews booked within 48 hours of application A firm offer within a week of the final interview Sell the Role, Not Just the Shift Candidates want to know why this venue, this team, this year. Talk about growth, autonomy, and what success looks like in the first six months. Skip the generic "fast paced environment" line, they've heard it a thousand times. Make the Process Feel Worth Their Time Every touchpoint is a chance to impress or lose them. Respond fast. Be transparent about salary. Give feedback even when it's a no. Word travels fast in hospitality circles, and your reputation as an employer matters as much as your reputation with guests. Where Hospoworld Fits In This is where a specialist recruiter earns its keep. Hospoworld works permanent hospitality placements only, across NZ and Australia, which means we already know the experienced managers and chefs you're trying to reach. CHECKLIST: Are You Set Up to Attract Top Hospitality Talent? ☐ Can you interview within 48 hours of application? ☐ Is your salary range clear from the first conversation? ☐ Does your job ad sell career growth, not just duties? ☐ Do you give feedback to every candidate, yes or no? ☐ Would your current team recommend working for you? If you ticked less than four, it's time to tighten up. Ready to build a team of hospitality Candidates who stay? Talk to Hospoworld today .
By RWR Group Marketing • August 24, 2026
Learn how employee storytelling reduces hospitality turnover and attracts top talent across Australia and New Zealand.
By RWR Group Marketing • August 17, 2026
Discover why passive candidates make the best hospitality hires and learn the exact strategies to reach them across Australia and New Zealand.
By RWR Group Marketing • August 10, 2026
Learn how to position yourself for roles before your industry peers do.
By RWR Group Marketing • August 3, 2026
Discover how to retain hospitality managers in Australia and New Zealand by building a culture where leaders thrive.
By RWR Group Marketing • July 27, 2026
How are hospitality operators using recruitment analytics to hire better and faster? Hospoworld explains the data-driven approach transforming hiring in NZ and AU.
By RWR Group Marketing • July 20, 2026
Need an experienced hospitality leader urgently? These proven strategies help NZ and AU venues attract and secure senior talent fast without compromising on quality.