How to combat the counter offer

If you are responsible for recruitment within your team or organisation you’ve no doubt experienced how competitive the current candidate market is. The number of vacancies listed in the healthcare sector is growing, yet with border restrictions and the fear of uncertainty, there are fewer candidates actively applying for roles.


Active job seekers hold the power with many being in situations where they have multiple offers on the table, from both other opportunities or their current employers in a bid to retain them. In order to ensure a successful recruitment outcome for your vacancy, you must anticipate that multiple and counteroffers are more prevalent than ever and could impact your recruitment process. 


At every touchpoint engage with your candidate, seek to understand what other roles they are considering or in the process for. This will help discover the appeal of other opportunities and understand how your offer is positioned against them. Benchmark your offer (remuneration and benefits) to ensure it meets what others in the market are offering. This doesn’t necessarily mean increasing the salary (although in some instances this will work) there are other factors equally important to job seekers in the current market. Work/life balance has fast become one of the biggest motivating factors for candidates to seek a new opportunity, evaluating your roster structure to accommodate this will help your opportunity stand out. The ability to be flexible with your offer demonstrates to a candidate that you invested in a long term partnership with them. 


In order to mitigate the risk of your preferred candidate accepting a counter offer there are steps you can take from the start to set yourself up for success. First and foremost, a clear timeline from the 1st interview through to the job offer will provide structure and keep the wheels moving.  Regularly check in with your applicants to keep them engaged - even letting them know there are no updates is an update to them. If there are multiple stakeholders involved that will be a part of your 2nd or 3rd interview book those interview times in their calendars from the outset - the scramble to align everyone’s schedules towards the end of the process adds pressure and stress that can easily be avoided by organising this in advance. Time is precious and waiting for calendars to align could mean the difference between a candidate accepting an offer that has already been presented to them instead of waiting for you. 


Ensure you and your team are ready to sell your brand and promote all the great things about working in your business. When engaging a potential new hire, share the importance of the role, the challenges they may face (for many candidates this is a positive opportunity for them to make a difference to your organisation and customers), outline the training that will be provided throughout onboarding and ongoing and lastly share examples of others in your business; when they started, how they progressed and the long-term progression pathways available within the company. Be honest and open, there should be no questions left unanswered - the more information a candidate has, the easier it is for them to make the decision to join your team. 


Checklist:

  • Your position description is up to date and ready to share
  • Process and timeline in place and all stakeholders engaged (ideally 5-10 days max)
  • Market checked your remuneration and benefits on offer
  • Does your job advertisement position the vacancy well to stand out in this market?
  • Candidate engagement plan - all aboard and ready to sell your organisation and job opportunity


Our team has experienced the surge in counteroffers firsthand, they’re more than happy to chat with you in more detail about how your business can overcome this and ensure you have a successful recruitment outcome.


By RWR Group Marketing July 27, 2026
How are hospitality operators using recruitment analytics to hire better and faster? Hospoworld explains the data-driven approach transforming hiring in NZ and AU.
By RWR Group Marketing July 20, 2026
Need an experienced hospitality leader urgently? These proven strategies help NZ and AU venues attract and secure senior talent fast without compromising on quality.
By RWR Group Marketing July 13, 2026
Senior hospitality candidates evaluate much more than salary. Here is what hospitality leaders want before they say yes to a new role in NZ and AU.
By RWR Group Marketing July 6, 2026
You cannot afford to guess Salary is rarely the only reason a candidate accepts or rejects a role. But if your package is out of step with the market, the best people will not even get to the interview stage. They will see the number and move on. In a sector where skilled professionals at management and chef level are in genuinely short supply, getting your salary positioning right is not a nice-to-have. It is a competitive advantage. What the Market Is Paying Hospoworld consultants have access to live salary data across New Zealand and Australia every single week. Here is the current landscape for permanent management-level roles. Why Operators Get This Wrong The most common mistake is benchmarking against what you paid last time. The market moves fast. A salary that attracted strong candidates 18 months ago may now sit below the midpoint of what comparable roles are offering. The second mistake is treating base salary as the only number that matters. Candidates in this space are sophisticated. They look at the total package: performance bonuses, meals, accommodation, professional development, flexibility and genuine growth pathways. The Cost of Not Getting it Right A candidate who accepts a below-market salary often does so with one foot out the door. They keep their options open. Six months in, they move. You absorb the cost of another recruitment process, a gap in operations and the time it takes a new hire to reach full productivity. Get the number right the first time and you protect your investment in that hire. Three Steps to a Stronger Salary Offer Request a current salary benchmark from your Hospoworld consultant before you post the role. We will give you a live read on what comparable candidates in your market are currently earning. Build flexibility into your offer. Know your floor and your ceiling before you make the call. Candidates respect a confident, clear offer. Present the full package. If your base sits at the midpoint but your benefits are strong, lead with the total value. Make it easy for the candidate to say yes. Ready to check your salary positioning before your next hire? Talk to Hospoworld. We benchmark salaries across NZ and AU every week and we will give you a straight answer. Visit www.hospoworld.com to connect with your nearest consultant.
Green recruitment banner with staff illustrations and headline about improving staff retention
By RWR Group Marketing June 10, 2026
Staff retention in hospitality is declining. Discover key insights and strategies to improve retention in your business.
Green healthcare careers webpage with a central doctor illustration and floating salary cards
By RWR Group Marketing May 14, 2026
Explore high-paying hospitality roles in NZ, including Venue GMs & Executive Chefs. Find out what it takes to succeed today!
Green-themed banner with a bartender serving a drink under the text “Why Your Best Hire This Year Probably Isn’t on Seek.”
By RWR Group Marketing May 7, 2026
Top candidates aren't on job boards. Learn how to find the best talent in hospitality with our expert recruitment services.
Green infographic showing a stressed job candidate reading a hospital job ad on a phone, with laptop on desk
By RWR Group Marketing April 30, 2026
Learn how senior hospitality candidates interpret job ads to assess culture & growth. Prepare effectively for your next career move.
By RWR Group Marketing April 7, 2026
Discover how hospitality professionals in Australia and New Zealand can strategically pivot their careers, leveraging skills, networking and market insights to find the right opportunities.
By Shazamme System User March 26, 2026
In today’s competitive hospitality market across Australia and New Zealand, retention is considered a survival strategy and has become a necessity. High turnover continues to challenge venues, yet one key insight is often overlooked: Retention begins during recruitment and not after onboarding. Hiring the right people is only part of the solution. Setting clear expectations, aligning values and creating early engagement can significantly improve long-term retention. Why This Matters Candidates in hospitality are no longer just looking for a job. They’re looking for stability, career growth and a positive workplace culture. If these aren’t communicated early on, even the best hires may leave within months. 3 Practical Tips to Improve Retention Through Recruitment 1. Hire for Culture & Skill Technical skills can be trained, but attitude and cultural fit are harder to change. Screen for alignment with your team’s pace, values and service style. 2. Be Transparent About the Role Clearly communicate hours, peak periods and expectations. Misaligned expectations are one of the top causes of early turnover. 3. Create a Strong First Impression Your hiring process reflects your brand. Prompt communication, organised interviews, and a warm onboarding experience build trust from day one. Retention-Focused Hiring Checklist ☐ Clear and accurate job descriptions ☐ Defined career progression pathways ☐ Structured onboarding plan (first 30 days) ☐ Competitive and transparent compensation ☐ Strong employer branding (reviews, social presence) ☐ Regular communication during hiring process ☐ Feedback loop for unsuccessful candidates Take Action Audit Your Current Hiring Process Map out your candidate journey from the job ad to the first shift. Identify where candidates may feel uncertain or disengaged. Introduce a Realistic Job Preview Offer trial shifts or honest walkthroughs of a typical workday. This filters out mismatched candidates early and builds commitment from those who stay. Key Takeaway Retention is about hiring smarter from the start. Businesses that invest in better recruitment processes will see stronger teams, improved morale and ultimately, better guest experiences. Ready to Build a More Reliable Team? If you want to reduce turnover and attract hospitality talent that stays, Hospoworld Resourcing can help. Our tailored recruitment approach connects you with candidates who fit your business. Visit these pages on our website to learn more and access additional hiring resources that can transform your team’s stability and performance: Our Recruiting Expertise Insights (Blogs)